Wednesday, September 22, 2010

Another assault to the Turkish history by an Australian media;

http://www.abc.net.au/unleashed/stories/s3008191.htm

When the prominent Melbourne academic and activist Jessie Webb returned from Geneva as Australia's representative to the General Assembly of the League of Nations (predecessor to the United Nations) in 1923, she made a strong appeal to the nation's women. She urged them to support the League's efforts to reclaim the thousands of Armenian women and children in Turkey who had been abducted into Muslim households during the Armenian genocide in 1915 and forcibly converted to Islam.
Webb was among a large number of prominent Australians who had mobilised to help survivors through the Armenian Relief Fund, arguably Australia's first international humanitarian aid effort. Established in Victoria in 1915, and supported by the major churches, the fund soon formed branches in every state in the country.
Major appeals were launched, calling on Australians to donate money and goods.
The collected goods were sent directly to the destitute Armenian refugees aboard the Commonwealth government line of steamers which the then prime minister, Billy Hughes, had promised would be free of charge.
The relief movement culminated in the establishment of an Australian-run orphanage in Beirut, Lebanon, for 1700 Armenian orphans. By 1927, tens of thousands of Armenians were still held in captivity awaiting reclamation.Eight decades later, visiting for this year's Melbourne Writers Festival, is author and Turkish human rights lawyer, Fethiye Çetin. Presenting her book, My Grandmother, a memoir of Çetin's discovery of her Muslim grandmother's true Armenian Christian identity, Fethiye's grandmother was among those who were not reclaimed.When Fethiye was growing up, she knew her grandmother as a universally respected Muslim housewife.
It would be decades before her grandmother told her the truth: that she was by birth an Armenian Christian. She went on to tell the dramatic story of being saved from a death march by a Turkish gendarme captain who then adopted her and expressed her desire to connect with her remaining true family in America.Like Fethiye, most Australian Armenians, including myself, are descendants of those who survived the death marches of 1915.

They have brought with them many stories of survival and of lost relatives. It was by all accounts, the darkest episode in Armenia's history of over 3 millennia. Viewed by some historians as equal in intent and trauma as the Jewish Holocaust, denial surrounds this period - officially in Turkey, as well as among many Turkish and Armenian families.

And despite Australia's part in the relief efforts, this history is mostly unknown to the wider population. Fethiye Çetin's memoir and visit serve to bring this history and its personal stories to our attention.Fethiye's grandmother's story will resonate with Australians as a reminder of our nation's own Stolen Generation. But it is also a reminder of the proud moment when we joined in a global effort to save the survivors of one of the most horrific events in modern history.
In Australia, this landmark response was an early manifestation of the humanitarian ethos that formed part of the nation's engagement with international movements throughout the past century.

Vicken Babkenian is an independent researcher for the Australian Institute for Holocaust and Genocide Studies.

Fethiye Çetin is in Australia as part of the Melbourne Writer's Festival.
For more details see www.spinifexpress.com.au

2 comments:

Julia Gul Arslan ( Australia-Gallipoli Friendship Society inc) said...

Armenian Genocide claims versus 'Johnny Turks/Honourable Enemy’ which Described By The Australians...

I am so surprise that despite of millions of innocent Turkish loss why no one mentions about where millions of Turks who killed during the war the great war?
Firstly, Armenian children weren’t abducted, they were saved. Also, they weren’t forcibly converted to Islam because of in Islam; the first teaching in Islamic studies is; there is no “forcing” at all. Forcing issue is against to Islamic religion rules.
If she saved and adopted by a Turkish gendarme captain isn’t that mean Turkish gendarme has more humane than an American soldiers in Iraq recorded ugly crimes more than 80 years later, is this mean man progressing or not?. Do you condemn the today’s Americans or allied soldiers as well?
How would you describe as a “genocide” if your country citizens were armed and fought against to your country people?

How would you describe the Turkish genocide towards to the Armenian whereas very kind, fair, gentlemen to towards to the Anzacs in 1915?

I will leave it to the Anzacs that defends the Turks;

"Turks have treated our captured men and officers excellently" The diary of the Aus. Official Corres. C.E.W.Bean


“You will hear extraordinary horrible stories practiced by Turks. Well, don’t believe a word of them. They are grossly exaggerated if not wholly false. You will be surprised at the gentlemanly way the Turks has fought us.” Jim Haynes (Cobbers - Stories of Gallipoli 1915 p. 178)

I reckon the Turk respects us, as we respect the Turk, Abdul's a good, clean fighter - we've fought him, and we know" Lieutenant Oliver Hogue

"The Turks have always proved themselves perfectly willing to have armistices and have actually asked for one at Helles which was refused by our General Staff. " Ashmead-Bartlett's Diary,1915

" They (Turks) too were fighting for their country. Good and fair fighters. No. They fought very fair and honestly like us. Both sides lost their very valuable men.” [E.W.BARTLETT - was born in Australia , 1891. 11. Light Horse Regiment. One Hundred years old. He was one of last two hundred who left the Dardanelle.]

"The Turkish sniper understood that we were searching for him. He shot once and the doctor got wounded. When he realized that he was a doctor, he didn’t shoot again.”
Exerted from Sydney Alexander Moseley, former war correspondent during the Gallipoli Campaign ”

“ After the terrible punishment inflicted upon the brave but futile assaults all bitterness faded … The Turks displayed an admirable manliness … From that morning onwards the attitude of the Anzac troops towards the individual Turks was rather that of opponents in a friendly game” [ Charles. E Bean, the Australian official historian, The Story of Anzac, Vol II, Sydney, 1924, p.162 ]

"The Anzacs left Gallipoli without hatred in their heart for their enemy or bitterness at the incompetence of their own high command.” A.K. Macdouggall, Australian historian

More collections can be found in the book called;
Johnny Turks – Memoirs on Gallipoli by Julia Gul Arslan

Julia Gul Arslan ( Australia-Gallipoli Friendship Society inc) said...

Armenian Genocide claims versus 'Johnny Turks/Honourable Enemy’ which Described By The Australians...

I am so surprise that despite of millions of innocent Turkish loss why no one mentions about where millions of Turks who killed during the war the great war?
Firstly, Armenian children weren’t abducted, they were saved. Also, they weren’t forcibly converted to Islam because of in Islam; the first teaching in Islamic studies is; there is no “forcing” at all. Forcing issue is against to Islamic religion rules.
If she saved and adopted by a Turkish gendarme captain isn’t that mean Turkish gendarme has more humane than an American soldiers in Iraq recorded ugly crimes more than 80 years later, is this mean man progressing or not?. Do you condemn the today’s Americans or allied soldiers as well?
How would you describe as a “genocide” if your country citizens were armed and fought against to your country people?

How would you describe the Turkish genocide towards to the Armenian whereas very kind, fair, gentlemen to towards to the Anzacs in 1915?

I will leave it to the Anzacs that defends the Turks;

"Turks have treated our captured men and officers excellently" The diary of the Aus. Official Corres. C.E.W.Bean


“You will hear extraordinary horrible stories practiced by Turks. Well, don’t believe a word of them. They are grossly exaggerated if not wholly false. You will be surprised at the gentlemanly way the Turks has fought us.” Jim Haynes (Cobbers - Stories of Gallipoli 1915 p. 178)

I reckon the Turk respects us, as we respect the Turk, Abdul's a good, clean fighter - we've fought him, and we know" Lieutenant Oliver Hogue

"The Turks have always proved themselves perfectly willing to have armistices and have actually asked for one at Helles which was refused by our General Staff. " Ashmead-Bartlett's Diary,1915

" They (Turks) too were fighting for their country. Good and fair fighters. No. They fought very fair and honestly like us. Both sides lost their very valuable men.” [E.W.BARTLETT - was born in Australia , 1891. 11. Light Horse Regiment. One Hundred years old. He was one of last two hundred who left the Dardanelle.]

"The Turkish sniper understood that we were searching for him. He shot once and the doctor got wounded. When he realized that he was a doctor, he didn’t shoot again.”
Exerted from Sydney Alexander Moseley, former war correspondent during the Gallipoli Campaign ”

“ After the terrible punishment inflicted upon the brave but futile assaults all bitterness faded … The Turks displayed an admirable manliness … From that morning onwards the attitude of the Anzac troops towards the individual Turks was rather that of opponents in a friendly game” [ Charles. E Bean, the Australian official historian, The Story of Anzac, Vol II, Sydney, 1924, p.162 ]

"The Anzacs left Gallipoli without hatred in their heart for their enemy or bitterness at the incompetence of their own high command.” A.K. Macdouggall, Australian historian

More collections can be found in the book called;
Johnny Turks – Memoirs on Gallipoli by Julia Gul Arslan